green banana
Jul 21, 2025
EB1C 140 RFE managerial roles
I got an RFE on my 140 recently, it’s asking for additional evidence that both foreign and U.S. positions are managerial roles. I was a people manager abroad and now a functional manager after moving to U.S. Abroad: I provided the evidence that i participated in interview, hire, fire, task deligation, manage budget, give performance feedback. org chart. reports resume US: org chart. Indirect reports. evidence of interview records, attend board meetings, job descriptions Can anyone give me some suggestions on what other documents I should provide? #eb1c #RFE
8
ADVERTISEMENT
a
amdsk aJul 21, 2025
@green banana my best advice is to consult your attorney
Ann VoigJul 21, 2025
I received a very similar RFE, but I was a manager both overseas and here. I think you can include any documentation that shows you have strategic oversight and that you are involved in high level decisions. are you involved in any budget planning processes? were you managing a department or an essential activity? you can include emails that show you have given approval on high level processes
J
Joseph ClimberJul 21, 2025
mostly show that you’re on senior managerial level, not the person actually doing the work. write your job description with a breakdown of % time you spend in each task. make sure at least 60% of the time is on high level managerial tasks, not you doing the work. show email, chats, meeting of you directing teams, scheduling training. show meeting agendas/invites of meetings with senior leadership or executives in which you are presenting updates of strategic initiatives. show evidence of decision making.
María UlloaJul 22, 2025
i provided a bunch of emails, decks, and meetings
green bananaJul 22, 2025
@María Ulloa thanks, for the meetings, do you just provide the screenshot? also how many pages of evidence did you provide? for example if have conduct over 100 interviews, do I need to screenshot all or a couple should be sufficient?
J
Joseph ClimberJul 22, 2025
put only the most impactful examples
María UlloaJul 23, 2025
screenshots -I selected the most important ones, meetings and emails, and made a .doc with screenshots and a brief 2 sentences description for each screenshot - In total it was like 20 items per position (abroad and U.S.) plus 4-3 important decks and org charts…
María UlloaJul 23, 2025
btw, in the description of the screenshots I tried to use the language from the USCIS website that proves managerial function.

Popular hashtags