gb pwl
Sep 17, 2021
RFE on Birth certificate
hi friends, need some help on the birth certificate rfe. I had submitted notarized affidavits from father and mother and supporting school leaving certificates but still got an rfe on the 485 process so late in the game!. I have a government municipal document stating my birth but it doesnt have my name on it. Should I submit this govt document and new affidavits? The government in India, mumbai will not issue a new birth certificate or a non availability certificate, They just wont give it, even if I paid for it. Would really appreciate responses on what to submit. Unfortunately my lawyer is useless, cant seem to get information from them. Thankyou!
EB3-3
Unskilled worker (requiring less than 2 years of training or experience)
Total Days: 1726 days
Case
2020-10-28
Today
I-131
471 Days
I-485
1726 Days
National Benefits Center: I-131, I-485
Timeline Map
2013-08-15
I-485
D-2631
Priority Date
2020-10-28
I-131
I-485
Submission to USCIS
2021-08-16
I-131
D+292
Biometrics, i.e. fingerprint and photo
2022-02-11
I-131
D+471
Decision (Approval or Denial)
2024-09-21
I-485
D+1424
Biometrics, i.e. fingerprint and photo
2024-09-25
I-485
D+1428
Request for Evidence(RFE) from USCIS
2024-11-07
I-485
D+1471
Response to RFE
This timeline was created with the Lawfully App. Download the Lawfully App now.
ADVERTISEMENT
itty kkSep 17, 2021
try passport office.. local
itty kkSep 17, 2021
Random QuerySep 17, 2021
to Clarify: Is the RFE you received on July 30th related to Birth Certificate ? It shows that you responded to the RFE on Aug 17th. Or did you get a new RFE some time now ? I am asking for some Background Information. I am born In Saudi and I don't have a BC for the local authority there...neither they provide NAC... So as per the USCIS Title 8 of code of federal regulations 103.2 (b)(2)(ii) I submitted a Notarized Cover letter, drafted by me showing all my good faith attempts to recover the Birth Certificate (emails, affidavits) and the Secondary Evidences I have to proving my birth place (School Records, Consulate BC, Hospital Notification etc) along with Affidavits from Mom, Uncle and Aunt. I haven't received any query so far. I filed on 1st Feb 2021. Mine was tough as One might know how tough things can get in a Foreign country. But if nothing else works for you in India, please read the title I mentioned above and do accordingly. But please do lemme know if it's a second query that u received (July 30)
Waiting PatientlySep 17, 2021
if you have a legitimate reason, it should be ok. I was born in India… adopted to Canada at a very young age. never had a birth certificate and my green card was approved in 5-6 months when I married my American hubby
Ams GangsSep 17, 2021
wondering when u submitted rfe you need to go to court and get approval for birth certificate then the local office will issue it and this can take 3 to 4 months. Other options is to work with local office if they have not issued non availability letter they can do something for sure.
Waiting PatientlySep 17, 2021
lol it’s India, the officials just want a bribe. For a basic passport renewal 53% of people report having to pay a bribe. Even if they can send the birth certificate, have it in their possession as we speak… they want a bribe first. This is the problem with India sadly
Ams GangsSep 17, 2021
what is your priority date and what location
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
Application is at NBC, priority date is aug 2013, and location is MA, but rfe was posted from st thomas, virgin islands. how bizarre! haven’t heard of this place until now
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
hi Random query, thankyou for the information. my Aug 17 reaponse to rfe was for a 2 papers not signed on 485J supplement. I had signed them, looks like they were careless and lost them. I got EAD after that and 485J receipt, but the birth certificate rfe was on Sept 8, again I had submitted all similar documents mentioned by you. Looks like they are just not trained to chexk documents properly. Seems like it is a matter of luck if ones gets through .
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
Thankyou friends for all the feedback, all useful information. More experiences are appreciated.
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
yes got it just last week, and they say I should tey to submit before sept 30th to be eligible for this year quota. Why didn’t they give all rfes together? it’s ridiculous, I pay lawyer fees for each RFE
Random QuerySep 18, 2021
@gb pwl You are right... it's a matter of luck... but I'm still curious ? Did you submit a Notarized Cover Letter ? Did it include All the Good Faith Attempts. I included a Cover Letter (2 pages- Two Tables)
Ist Table- Good Faith Attempts to retrieve the Document. (Near About 6 attempts with the Dates I tried- Also enclosed Proofs as Attachment)
2nd Table:- Secondary Evidences to Prove Birth In Saudi Arabia (6 documents to Prove Birth which had my name, parents name and Birth Certificate and 3 Affidavits from people mentioned earlier)
Initially A paragraph explaining why I didn't have a local body issued birth Certificate.
Additionally if it might help you... I'm an Indian citizen born in Saudi. So I also made a late registration Birth Certificate from The Panchayat ( it has my name, parents name, Place of Birth as Saudi)
Let me know if this helps. I really wish it does. Again, as you said it depends on the officer there. To make the Indian Panchayat BC, it took nearly 2 months.
itty kkSep 18, 2021
the passport office trick doesn't work ?
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
yes it was notarized
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
Thankyou so much Randome query. I will add cover letters and update you on how it goes. wish you goodluck as well!
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
passport office doesnt work, and Indian consul gices non availability for only those born before 1969.
Random QuerySep 18, 2021
@gb pwl Good luck to you...Cover letter is a must! Please read the Title I mentioned earlier. Title 8 103. It has very good explanation. Will help you to answer the query more efficiently. Also the good faith Attempts. All the Best to you..🙏
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
👍👍🙏
itty kkSep 18, 2021
all the best..
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
@Random query, can you recommend a lawyer or a legal person who can help to write these notarized documents, not sure how to send you a direct message
Random QuerySep 18, 2021
Hi... Even though we have a lawyer, all the Cover letter drafting we did by ourselves,after thorough reading of the guidelines and some prior experience posted by people on various websites. If you can share your email here, I will share the Template of the Cover letter. Additionally, please keep in mind that we are also in the wait period and we haven't yet received our GC... neither any queries for the same yet. So we might not be the Ultimate answer, but happy to help you with what we did.
gb pwlSep 18, 2021
no worries, yes please send me drafts, anything helps, my lawyer has not been much help.. email staybnyc@gmail.com
Random QuerySep 18, 2021
Sent!
I NOct 1, 2021
I got RFE for name issue in birth certificate on 9/17. submitted my affidavit and school certificate. let’s see what happens 🤞
gb pwlOct 1, 2021
goodluck @I N , please let me know if this was accepted and approved
Random QueryOct 1, 2021
@gb pwl Hope you remember 😊 just checking to see if you replied to your query ? And I received my EAD approval on 27th September. So fingers crossed I'm hoping that the only query that should come now is the Medicals. I'll be surprised if anything related to BC comes.... lemme know how yours went...and if you responded with the cover letter and good faith Attempts ?
gb pwlOct 1, 2021
hi @Random Query! 😊 I did reply this week with letters as you suggested . It took about 10 days to get new affidavits etc. and medicals. Its all submitted, so I will update on what I hear back. congratulations on EAD approval. you should get medical request soon. So do call different places to get idea on how soon you can get appointment for blood tests. For me it took 5 days to finish it all.
Random QueryOct 1, 2021
thank you😊 We have an appointment to do the medicals tomorrow 😊Best Wishes to you.
I NOct 1, 2021
have responded on Tuesday. let’s see how long they take to acknowledge and respond back
I NOct 1, 2021
my experience with Nebraska is no sooner than a month to get a response from the date sent
I NOct 4, 2021
any update on the cases anyone?
gb pwlOct 5, 2021
In my case, I may not get an update until a month as per my lawyer. So please keep checking your online for your uscis case status
I NOct 8, 2021
any one got any update
Random QueryOct 8, 2021
I didn't receive any RFE yet for my BC... (I didn't have the actual BC...Applied with cover letter and other docs) . Sept 27th I received the EAD.... now fingers crossed 🤞 Praying that the only query that comes is Medicals.. hasn't come so far.....We hadn't submitted medicals initially...!!
I NOct 16, 2021
any update folks?
gb pwlOct 16, 2021
not yet! final action date has retrogressed for EB3 to Jan 11, so they might keep applications on hold, my priority date is Aug 13.
Random QueryNov 4, 2021
gb pwl ... I received notification that Request for Additional Evidence is sent .... I can't wait to get my hands on it... I'm scared if it has to do anything with the birth certificate. I have a question for you... when you received ur query .. was it a RFIE or RF Additional ? Kindly answer
Nov 21, 2022
@Random Query....what was the final outcome
gb pwlNov 21, 2022
hi sorry for late reply @random query , I only got an Rfe and this was last year in Aug 2021. as of now, when I contacted uscis service agent sbout outcome and whether my birth certificate was accepted. They dont give a straight answer. She said “if you haven’t received anything other rfe, then they may not ask for now” This is still confusing to me, because my application is pending since 1.5 years. I dont know what the heck is going on.
gb pwlNov 21, 2022
Ai would say call the service agent and ask to speak to 2nd tier officer for your specific questions. you can also ask them to email you the digital rfe if it takes a long time to reach bu mail
